[Home vs. Cloud] PlayOn Review: Is It Still the Best DVR Tool?

Cutting the cord was supposed to be the ultimate freedom—save money, ditch the cable box, and watch whatever, whenever. But as a guy who spends way too much time optimizing his Plex Media Server, I quickly hit a wall: How do I actually own the movies and games I'm streaming?

For years, PlayOn was the only tool in my arsenal that could legally record streams from Netflix or Hulu to fill up those hard drives. It was the "OG" streaming DVR. But here we are in 2025, PlayOn Home has changed its pricing (again), and PlayOn Cloud is pushing a credit system that makes my wallet itch.

In this PlayOn review, I'll make a detailed analysis of its new services, pricing system, hidden coding method, the ugly truth about PlayOn's limitations, and its binding with Plex. If you want a real 1080p source file, do not miss the alternative part.

What is PlayOn? Service, Price, and Working Pattern

If you're new to the PlayOn ecosystem, the naming might look like a simple "Desktop vs. Mobile" choice. But the fact is a bit more complicated than that. PlayOn split its service into two distinct products after it killed off the old "PlayOn Desktop". Now we have PlayOn Home and PlayOn Cloud.

PlayOn Home vs. PlayOn Cloud: Which One Should You Choose?

Despite these differences, the type of content that you get is mostly the same, except for Cloud's unique cloud facilities that aren't available in PlayOn Home.

Before we jump into the details of each product, let's address the most important problem: Is PlayOn free to use, and what's the difference in the pricing model between Home and Cloud?

How Much is PlayOn?

Neither the PlayOn desktop nor the mobile versions are free. They come with different subscription models.  In fact, it operates like an old-school arcade—you either pay a cover charge (Subscription) or you buy tokens (Credits).

For PlayOn Home, it requires a monthly or annual subscription. Although you can register for and use a Home Free account, the highest resolution you can get is SD 480p (I can't believe anyone needs this in 2025).

• Normal Price: $39.99/year or $14.97/ a quarter (3 months)
• Sale Price: $99.98 for 5 years during campaigns. While this breaks down to a cheap ~$20/year, remember, you are locking yourself into 720p resolution for half a decade.

For PlayOn Cloud, it's free to install, but every single recording and storage space both requires credits. Want to record a whole season of Stranger Things? You'd better have a stack of credits ready.

• Free trial: 7 free credits (expire in 7 days)
• Cloud Storage: $4.99 for 100GB, $9.99 for 500 GB, $16.99 for 1TB, $29.99 for 2TB, $49.99 for 4TB
• Cloud Credit: $7.5 for 50 credits, $35 for 250 credits, $65 for 500 credits.

Rex

If you're a data hoarder like me and have your own SSD, there is no need to pay for the Cloud Storage. After all, it's not cheap and expires.

Different Features and Working Patterns of Cloud and Home

Based on my own usage experience, PlayOn Home is more like an "old school" server method, and PlayOn Cloud is a kind of "convenience" tax.

PlayOn Home can turn a Windows PC into a DVR (not available for Mac). This is what I use on my dedicated media server. It's best for people who have a PC running 24/7 anyway and want to schedule recordings to happen while they sleep.

• How it works: You install the .exe on your PC. It uses your internet bandwidth and your CPU to play the video in a hidden background window and record it in real-time.
• The Catch: It is strictly capped at 720p, although you have a Ryzen 9 processor and a gigabit fiber.

PlayOn Cloud is the modern, mobile-friendly version. It runs on their servers, not ours. Unlike Home, Cloud can record in 1080p.

• How it works: You initiate a recording via the iOS or Android app. Their cloud servers do the heavy lifting, record the stream, and send you an .mp4 file to download.
• The Catch: It costs extra credits for 1080p. Also, once the recording is done, you only have a few days to download it before they delete it from the cloud to save space. If you forget to download it? Your credit is gone, and so is the file.

Is it Legal and Safe to Use PlayOn?

Is it legal to use PlayOn? Will my Netflix account get banned for using PlayOn? Based on my own usage experience (for 3 months) and the investigation of the user forum, it's generally acceptable.

Generally speaking, PlayOn operates under the concept of "Time-Shifting": We are paying for the content via our Netflix subscription, and we are making a personal recording to watch it offline at a later time.

As long as you keep the files for personal use and do NOT distribute, share, or sell them, you are typically within the bounds of Fair Use.

Reex

However, keep in mind that this violates the Terms of Service (ToS) of most streaming platforms. While I haven't heard of users getting banned just for recording, I am a tech blogger, not a lawyer.

This is not legal advice, just the general consensus in the cord-cutting community.

Cons of PlayOn: What You Should Know Before Paying?

It cannot be denied that PlayOn is the pioneer of video recording. But after using it for months to curate my Plex library, the problems started showing up. If you are serious about video quality or have a large library to build, here is the raw, unfiltered truth you need to know before you swipe that credit card.

You can check Audials VS PlayOn to know more.

This is the biggest deal-breaker for PlayOn Home users. It is capped at 720p (HD). Doesn't matter if you pay for their Premium 4K plans of Netflix, Disney+, or Amazon. PlayOn Home will downscale it to 720p. PlayOn Cloud can do 1080p, but you are paying credits for every single file. It gets expensive fast.

Since PlayOn is technically a screen capture tool (recording the playback), it records at 1x speed. It takes 3 hours to download a 3-hour Avengers movie. Want to binge-download a 10-season show? See you next month.

While recording, PlayOn Home monopolizes your PC's resources. If you try to game or edit video while it's running, expect your recording to stutter or fail.

Complaints such as "PlayOn recording failed" or "PlayOn recording stuck" are normal on Reddit. Because PlayOn relies on a virtual browser, any slight hiccup can kill the recording.

If your internet dips for a second, the recording might fail. If your PC gets overloaded, the video stutters. If Netflix changes its UI layout slightly, PlayOn's "browser" might get confused and fail to start the video. I've woken up too many mornings expecting a season of The Office to be ready, only to find a list of red "Failed" icons.

PlayOn uses algorithms to detect where commercials are (usually black frames or audio dips) and skips them. It works most of the time. But I've had plenty of recordings where it chopped off the last 10 seconds of a scene or missed a commercial entirely.

Rex

One more tip about PlayOn's audio: There is no 5.1 Surround Sound. PlayOn only records in Stereo (2.0) audio. If you have a nice home theater setup, this is a massive letdown.

Best PlayOn Alternative: KeepStreams

If you're building your own offline video library and want high-quality files in 1080p, 4K with 5.1 surround Sound or Dolby Atmos, PlayOn's features might be a bit limited for your needs. I did some comparison between PlayOn and several alternatives and compared their pricing, features, pros, and cons. Read PlayOn Desktop and Best Alternative to get more info.

Among these alternatives, KeepStreams is one of the best tools I've used. Every week, I need to save TV shows, sports games, and films from different streaming services. And KeepStreams's Auto-Download function can perfectly save my time and energy.

Different from PlayOn, KeepStreams directly extracts the source video files from the streaming site and saves videos in the original 1080p/4K, Atmos audio, EAC3 5.1 audio, with Dolby Vision, HDR10, VP9, or AV1 video codec. What's more, KeepStreams has 50+ modules and supports 3,000 streaming sites, including the major platforms and niche ones.

KeepStreams

Instead of recording, KeepStreams downloads 1080p/4K videos you want from the Internet directly. Save them on your hard drive and never worry about the "cloud storage" or credits!

• Batch Download at 10X speed.
• Save and extract subtitles into SRT files.
• Save videos in original 720p, 1080p, 4K quality.
• Downloads content in MP4/MKV for best compatibility.
• Support Atmos audio, EAC3 5.1, AAC 2.0, and AC3 5.1 audio.
• Apply H264, H265, HDR10, Dolby Vision, VP9, and AV1 video codec.
• Schedule downloads and save newly added videos automatically.
• Remove ads from downloaded videos (even with an ad-supported plan).
• Simplify the download process with a built-in browser.
• Save metadata.
• 30-day free trial to download 3 videos from each module.

 Free Trial  Free Trial

Learn More

How to Download Movies Using KeepStreams Downloader? As I mentioned above, it's pretty easy because of the built-in browser. Basically, you only need to follow 5 steps:

Launch the downloader, and from the Streaming Services option, choose the streaming service. For example, Netflix.

Now, you will be able to see movies and shows on Netflix there. Click the movie or series you want to download. KeepStreams will analyze it for you.

Here's a more detailed video introduction of KeepStreams from its official YouTube channel:

Bonus: The Ultimate Media Server Strategy

Before we wrap up, I want to share my usage experience with "PlayOn and Plex" and "KeepStreams and Plex". If you're building your own Plex library like me, don't skip this part to learn how to set up the ultimate automated pipeline with the 2 tools.

Using PlayOn with Plex is pretty straightforward. You set PlayOn Home to record a series, and you point your Plex library to PlayOn's output folder.

However, as we discussed, you are feeding your beautiful Plex interface with 720p, stereo-sound files. It's like buying a 4K projector and watching VHS tapes on it. Also, PlayOn's file naming can sometimes confuse Plex's metadata agents, leading to mismatched posters.

You can customize the output directory of KeepStreams, too. Set it in KeepStreams settings, change the "Output Directory" to a folder that your Plex Media Server monitors (e.g., D:\Movies or D:\TV Shows on your NAS).

Then, turn on "Download new episodes automatically" when setting download options on KeepStreams. Since KeepStreams downloads the files with cleaner naming conventions than PlayOn, just leave the rest things to PlayOn and KeepStreams.

Final Words

PlayOn is an excellent tool that can help you record and stream content. This PlayOn review answers every core question on PlayOn, including the legality, safety, working pattern, real drawbacks, and recommended PlayOn alternative. The answer to "should I keep using PlayOn?" actually depends on your needs:

If you are strictly looking for a simple way to record live streams or have a very slow internet connection where real-time recording is safer, PlayOn is still a decent tool. It's the "OG" for a reason.

But if you are here because you want to build a high-quality offline library, avoid the monthly subscription fees and cost of endless credits, and get actual HD/4K quality, KeepStreams is the upgrade you've been waiting for.